Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content

My Federal Disability

Helping Federal & Postal employees to get OPM Disability Retirement Benefits under FERS

My Federal Disability

Main menu

  • Home
  • About Me
  • Credentials
  • Copyright
  • Contact Us

Tag Archives: when non-attorneys attempt to use case law

Federal Disability Retirement: Further Comment on Vanieken-Ryals

Posted on August 16, 2008 by Federal Disability Lawyer
Reply

Vanieken-Ryals v. OPM, decided by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit on November 26, 2007, has an interesting statement from the deciding Judge, which can be used as “firepower” for anyone who is attempting to obtain Federal Disability Retirement benefits (note of caution:  for lay non-attorneys, be careful in how you use it in trying to convince a lay, non-attorney OPM representative):  “In addition, neither the MSPB nor OPM discussed the content of Dr. [ ] or [ ] evidence in any meaningful way, which further demonstrates that it was not properly considered.  OPM, for example, resorted to a laundry list of “objective” tests and documents that the medical evidence did not contain rather than examining the evidence and evaluating what it did contain.”

Interpretation:  If OPM’s argument is to focus upon what is missing, they have violated their primary Agency/administrative responsibility — that of evaluating, in some “meaningful” manner, the medical evidence which was in fact submitted.  This can be used effectively for the Reconsideration Stage by diplomatically pointing out the error of OPM, and citing Vanieken-Ryals, and highlighting the relevant portions of the medical documentation previously submitted.

Sincerely,

Robert R. McGill, Esquire

Posted in Application, Appeals, and Other Medical Documentation Submitted To the OPM, Federal Disability Judge-Made Decisions Quoted, Important Cases, Legal Updates and/or the Current Process Waiting Time | Tagged back pain and radiating pain along legs, case law citation in federal disabilities cases, disability laws for postal workers, disability retirement for postal clerks, disability retirement opm, Federal Circuit Court of Appeals, federal court decisions in OPM disability cases, federal employee disability compensation, federal workers disability, FERS disability lawyer, legal services for federal employees, letter carriers disability retirement, Massachusetts OPM disability retirement, medical benefits for nsf employees, medical evidence, medical reports in the OPM disability retirement applic, MSPB disability attorney, nationwide representation of federal employees, objective and subjective medical evidence, objective medical evidence for federal disability cases, office of personnel management retirement, one important legal interpretation of the opm's vanieken case, OPM decision making is not 100% rational or objective, OPM disability attorney, OPM Federal Government Disability Decisions, OPM Reconsideration Stage, pennsylvania opm disability retirement, physical inability removal, postal workers owcp rights attorney, representing federal employees from any us government agency, representing federal employees in and outside the country, statutes and regulations governing disability retirement law, the non-attorney opm representative, the opm must evaluate medical documentation, the Vanieken case, the Vanieken-Ryals case, Vanieken-Ryals v. Office of Personnel Management, when "objective medical evidence" is not necessary, when non-attorneys attempt to use case law, when the opm focuses on documentation you didn't submit, workers comp distribution clerks | Leave a reply

Search this OPM Medical Retirement website

Blogroll

  • Attorney Profile @ Avvo.com The attorney profile of Robert R. McGill, who specializes 100% of his time on Federal Retirement cases only. This page has more information about the law firm, client reviews and other important information.
  • Federal Disability Attorney More disability articles about FERS Disability Retirement benefits in the Federal Disability Attorney blog.
  • Federal Disability Retirement @ WordPress.com Daily information and updates about the Federal Retirement application, the Retirement process, new court cases, standard forms and many other tips and advice.
  • Federal Disability Retirement Home Page The home page of Attorney Robert R. McGill, with more medical administrative retirement articles, annuity calculators, statutory and evolving case laws, contact information and much more.

Archives

Categories

  • 1st Stage: The Initial Federal Retirement Claim
  • 2nd Stage: OPM Reconsideration Stage
  • 3rd Stage: MSPB Stage
  • 4th Stage: Petition for Full Review at the MSPB
  • Accommodation and Light Duty
  • Accommodation and Reassignment
  • Advantages of Federal Medical Retirement
  • Agency’s and/or Supervisor’s Actions
  • Application, Appeals, and Other Medical Documentation Submitted To the OPM
  • Basic Federal Disability Concepts
  • Burden of Proof
  • Clarifications of Laws or Rules
  • Evaluation Of Your Federal Medical Claim – How Do I Know If I Have A Strong Case?
  • FAQs and Potential Issues
  • Federal Disability and a Hostile Working Environment
  • Federal Disability Judge-Made Decisions Quoted
  • Federal Employees with Disabilities
  • FERS Accepted Medical Conditions
  • FERS Disability
  • FERS Disability Forms
  • Important Cases, Legal Updates and/or the Current Process Waiting Time
  • Important Rules and Considerations
  • Life after Federal Retirement
  • LWOP and Sick Leave in OPM Disability
  • Medical Documentation
  • Mental/Nervous Condition
  • Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB)
  • Miscellaneous
  • OPM Case Workers
  • OPM Disability & EEOC Complaints
  • OPM Disability & OWCP Workers Comp Filings
  • OPM Disability & SSA Social Security Disability Benefits
  • OPM Disability Application and/or Process
  • OPM Disability Retirement Application
  • OPM Medical Questionnaire
  • OWCP Disability Benefits
  • Parables and Stories
  • Post Application Issues
  • Postal Service
  • Preexisting Conditions
  • Professional & Expert Witnesses
  • Reasonable Medical Treatment and Compliance Issues
  • Reflections
  • Resigning or Being Separated From a Federal Agency for Medical Problems
  • SF 3112 Disability Retirement Application Package
  • SF 3112A Applicant's Statement of Disability for CSRS and FERS
  • SF 3112B Supervisor’s Statement for CSRS and FERS
  • SF 3112C Physician's Statement for CSRS and FERS
  • SF 3112D Agency Certification of Reassignment and Accommodation Efforts for CSRS and FERS
  • Some Preliminary Considerations
  • Strategies
  • The Agency
  • The Applicant
  • The Attorney
  • The Doctor
  • The Doctor
  • The Federal Agencies
  • The Federal Disability Lawyer
  • The Federal Disability Retirement Process
  • The Federal or Postal Supervisor
  • The Job of a Federal Disability Attorney
  • The MSPB Administrative Judge
  • The Office of Personnel Management
  • The OPM Representatives
  • The Others
  • U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB)
  • U.S. Office of Personnel Management (OPM)
  • U.S. Postal Service (USPS) & Medical Retirement
  • When The OPM Application Is Approved
  • When The OPM Application Is Denied

MAIN CONTENT

  • Home
  • About Me
  • Credentials
  • Copyright
  • Contact Us

Articles

  • 10 Common Mistakes Made in a Federal Disability Application
  • 20 Top Questions and Answers about OPM Disability Retirement
  • FERS Disability Retirement Calculator
  • Some Thoughts on Social Security and FERS Disability Retirement
The Federal Disability Attorney Network
Proudly powered by WordPress